logoalt Hacker News

lionkortoday at 9:37 AM1 replyview on HN

CHasm[0] is a bit of a joke, right? Did it take a lot of Claude massaging to get it to ignore basic engineering knowledge, like that compilers write better assembly than any other tool or person will (in the general case, which this is)?

This kind of summarizes the whole post for me. I struggle to see how, on a platform that I thought was passionate about engineering, this is gaining any kind of traction. Writing GUI tools in assembly, not to learn, but for whatever other reasons, is nightmarish levels of silly. I get the idea of making software TRULY yours. I get it. This isn't that. Letting an AI agent literally vibe code your entire desktop is not an idea that would come to anyone's mind as more than the punchline of a joke or a side note in a dystopian book.

You're not making software, Claude is. You're not learning anything, and the tools produced are (by design) not really editable.

0: https://github.com/isene/chasm


Replies

lpcvoidtoday at 10:14 AM

I agree. I have no idea why this story is upvoted. Hacker culture is truely dead, it's all slop now.