alt Hacker NewsAs I recall, “No Silver Bullet” fundamentally rested on the assumption that the subroutine was the last word in abstractions to make programming more efficient, which probably wasn’t even defensible at the time because Lisp had already been invented, and is even less defensible after the past several decades of programming language research. Brooks was still onto something when it came to irreducible complexity, but offloading complexity an LLM can tackle to the LLM still saves time.
One of the lesser discussed Brooks essays is actually the best description of AI-first development: the “surgical team”. It just turns out the surgeon is the only human, and like many modern surgeries, the surgeon is controlling a robot instead of operating by hand.
It would be interesting to reread The Mythical Man-Month and see how each essay applies to AI-first development.
The sibling comment to yours (by rafterydj) makes a good point that the surgical team is necessary, but we have eliminated the positions and put the roles on the same person. It’s like the writer being the subject expert, the reviewer, the editor,… which we all knows leads to mediocre work.