logoalt Hacker News

wahnfriedenyesterday at 7:57 PM6 repliesview on HN

You're missing that this is anti-AI activism


Replies

AlexanderHanfftoday at 12:15 PM

I am a computer scientist and have studied AI for over 30 years, I use AI every single day and I speak all over the world about the responsible and ethical use of AI... not sure how that makes me anti-ai?

I am a privacy activist and I strongly object to corporations reaching in to my device, changing the configuration and installing things I never asked for without telling me or requesting my permission. If that makes me anti-ai, then it is a hat I will wear with pride, thanks.

If you don't like that the law protects my position as opposed to your's, perhaps you could lobby to have the law changed, just as I have done for the last 20 years to make these laws stronger?

nvr219yesterday at 8:00 PM

We should be actively anti-AI being part of a web browser just like that though.

show 3 replies
pier25yesterday at 10:30 PM

It's not about AI. I'm pretty sure most people wouldn't be ok with eg a calculator app shipping a 4GB word processor.

croesyesterday at 8:00 PM

Maybe it’s pro-browser activism.

A browser should render web pages not bring its own AI

show 1 reply
detritusyesterday at 8:01 PM

It is? Or is it just a pragmatic dislike?

themafiayesterday at 8:51 PM

We don't have AI. We have language models trained by rapacious companies on copyrighted material with no concern for copyright violations and with a penchant for intentionally anthropomorhizing their models.

I'm an anti corporate malfeasance activist.

Hacker News and it's underemployed and underpaid user base gets these two confused all the time. I assure you, your tolerance for language models, or your willingness to use them, will have _zero_ impacts on your pay scale in the coming decade.

Finally you should be aware that Google markets this addition as an "anti fraud" and "anti spam" feature. They should have to justify that, I shouldn't have to justify my expectations as a consumer.

show 1 reply