alt Hacker News> * use systemd, red hat's favorite kitchen sink for handling everything
Systemd is a tool for managing services. Containers are services. Why require an entirely separate bespoke service manager when you're already running one?
> * docker compose where i have to run a whole separate podman service to lie to docker compose about not actually being docker.
This is the same system state as using docker compose with docker: you have a client program speaking to a backing daemon. Only difference here is the Podman service, being daemonless, only runs when needed (assuming you're setting up things the documented way by enabling the podman socket).
> * podman compose which would be the obvious solution if it didnt just plain suck.
Yeah I haven't had the best luck with it either. But part of the reason it's languished is that it makes more sense to just reimplement the Compose spec on the backend rather than re-invent the wheel and create a new compose client as well.
There's also the fourth option of writing Kubernetes yaml and applying that with `podman kube play`. Honestly this is probably closer to being the podman equivalent of docker compose but since it involves writing The Bad YAML (kubernetes) rather than The Good YAML (compose) most people don't use it.
>Systemd is a tool for managing services
It's a tool for user age verification that happens to be something you can use to manage services.
Did you miss my point about it being a filthy kitchen sink?
>This is the same system state as using docker compose with docker
One of the major selling points of podman is that you dont need a daemon. except maybe yes you do because podman compose sucks so toss that selling point in the trash.
This shit is also incredibly fiddly. Ever had "docker compose" and "docker-compose" do subtly different things which drive your team mate to pull their hair out? I have.
Podman should stop trying to piggyback off docker if it's trying to be an alternative.
>Yeah I haven't had the best luck with it either. But part of the reason it's languished is that it makes more sense to just reimplement the Compose spec on the backend
Personally I suspect it languished because Red Hat simply cant abide the idea that somebody out there might avoid using systemd for something.
They happily built a docker compose to quadlets converter but they cant bring themselves to make podman compose not be a piece of shit even though it wouldnt be a lot of work.