logoalt Hacker News

advaelyesterday at 11:30 PM1 replyview on HN

Wouldn't know if I'm a smart writer, but I see little value in writing with a model if that's what you're asking. Language models are good for searching, getting alright at structured outputs like code, and trash at meaningfully expressing my thoughts in prose. Frankly, it concerns me that people think vomiting their thoughts onto the internet could possibly benefit from computational assistance


Replies

serftoday at 12:24 AM

>Frankly, it concerns me that people think vomiting their thoughts onto the internet could possibly benefit from computational assistance

it concerns you because you have a good authority over your spoken language, and like most people with those skills I presume the language flows easily from you.

that ability isn't guaranteed, for a lot of people expression is tough, and those people felt equally alienated when confronted with an essay of word salad about why their opinion is wrong.

An LLM is a tool. In the 90s I would read columns and editorials about the disgusting faux pas of replying to a wedding invitation via such a cheap trendy medium like internet e-mail , now you receive death certificates that way.

It's not all bad, simpletons can use LLMs to have the critiquing essays turned into 5 word ELI5 statements that they can become enraged over once all the nuance is stripped. That's fun!

show 1 reply