logoalt Hacker News

lotuyesterday at 4:09 AM2 repliesview on HN

Yes but critically none of this money is actually given to the homeless person. So we aren't giving them anything for free we are just dealing with the consequences of them not having a proper support system. Spending money to do that is okay, because it doesn't really directly benefit the homeless person.


Replies

AnotherGoodNameyesterday at 4:15 AM

Also the essence of ‘San Francisco has a lot of homeless’ isn’t really a logical argument against those policies since homeless will often migrate to where the functional support services are. San Francisco may well be doing amazing things with getting people back on their feet at a relatively lower cost than prison.

You need to go many levels deeper on statistics to understand if it’s working or not.

show 2 replies
bpodgurskyyesterday at 6:06 PM

Sorry this is very wrong. SF has so many homeless people because they come to SF to get free things.

Most of that is not direct cash transfers but they absolutely receive more in services than in other places, that is why they attract homeless from all over the country.