logoalt Hacker News

cmrdporcupineyesterday at 8:05 PM1 replyview on HN

Exactly this.

I am not sure why people sound so astounded, to be honest. This has been my frank experience of the agentic tools both Codex and Claude since about December.

When given the right constraints this kind of thing is entirely conceivable.

However the important question not being answered here is: does anybody working on it have a full understanding of what has been built?

My experience having constructed similar types of projects using these tools is yes, you could do this in a week or two but now you'll have a month or two of digging through what it made, understanding what was built, and undoing critical yolo leaps of faith it made that you didn't want.


Replies

scuff3dyesterday at 8:50 PM

Not to mention to even attempt something like this from scratch would take hundreds of hours if spec work. I see it all day everyday in the aerospace sector. Software engineers have absolutely no idea what deriving a design document and all its associated artifacts actually looks like, and they're in for a rude surprise if the industry really does shift hard that direction