alt Hacker News> You could argue that I’m abusing 414 URI Too Long. I respond that it’s funnier this way. Other options I considered were:
Another option to consider is "418 I'm a teapot": teapots usually also don't support query strings
Replies
layer8 • yesterday at 8:39 PM
Of course they do. For example you can lower a string from the top to query the fill level. Or you can wrap a string around the pot to query the circumference.
Just straight "400" ("Bad Request") or "403" ("Forbidden") would also probably be defensible. Odd that there aren't any error response codes specific to URI parameters.
Several options which seem like they might be appropriate aren't on close examination:
- "406" ("Not Acceptable") which is based on content-negotiation headers.
- "409" ("Conflict") which is largely for WebDAV requests.
- Others such as 411, 422, and 431 are also for specific conditions which aren't relevant here.
- 300 or 500 errors are inappropriate as this isn't a relocation or server-side failure, it's a client-side request problem.
Teapot or too long seem best bets.