logoalt Hacker News

dangoodmanUTyesterday at 9:12 PM2 repliesview on HN

If this goes through, it feels like it will stoke rust on zig violence


Replies

leecommamichaelyesterday at 11:05 PM

I just wish the camps would stop being as tribalistic. I see a broad spectrum of fights between any "better C" language and Rust enthusiasts. There is room for both of these things. Just use what works for you. Rust is a bit more like Ada in spirit, it introduces a lot of friction compared to "C like" things which gladly accept you blowing your leg off. Each tool has unique benefits, and is uniquely suited to different problems.

If I'm building a simple GUI app, I'm not sure the friction from Rust is all that worthwhile. If I'm sending someone to space, I think I'd rather have the safeties of a Rust or an Ada, or MISRA C.

kennykartmanyesterday at 10:14 PM

Sadly, yes. I feel too much "violence" on both parts.

Honestly, Zig community seems the most bitter for whatever reason, while on the Rust side it seems to me that are simply overstating how great the language is and are pushy in trying to convince the other of their ideas.

If this goes through, we can all take SWE lessons from it, but I think the communities will suffer.