logoalt Hacker News

nullclast Sunday at 10:52 PM1 replyview on HN

but what if the alternatives are fundamentally worse? Turns out centralization has a lot of advantages.

I think it's an error to demand the alternatives be as good-- that might not even always be possible. But even if they're less good they're usually still better than anything we could have imagined decades ago-- they're good enough to use.

And that should be enough because we shouldn't consider handing control of ourselves to third parties to be an acceptable choice at all.


Replies

thomastjefferyyesterday at 12:57 PM

Let's dig into what makes them worse, and see what we can do about it.

I think the main struggle is moderation. Moderation requires a hierarchy, which is much more compatible with a centralized model. I'm thinking that curation would be a good alternative. Rather than authoritatively silencing unwanted content, just categorize it well enough for users to filter what they want.

show 1 reply