logoalt Hacker News

ai_fry_ur_braintoday at 5:19 AM2 repliesview on HN

The key is to not run LLMs in loops. This trend of agentic frameworks is silly, and mostly exists to make LLM companies more revenue. An LLM is mostly useless but is much more useful and reliable with one shot tooling.

I have a suite or tools ive built for myself on top of the openrouter api for very specific tasks. Press button amd LLM does (one) useful thing, not press button and let LLM run tool calls in a loop for 5 minutes and hope it does things in the correct order.

If multiple tools need to be called to do a useful thing, I will chain those together deterministically in my code. This is much more reliable as I can check the output of A before proceeding to task B or C, also its more time and token efficient. Agentic loops are a huge scam.


Replies

_fluxtoday at 10:28 AM

Often I find LLMs doing multiple steps to achieve some goals (e.g. do certain operations against JIRA or Gitlab), and if the LLM work seems useful, I instruct it to create a tool to achieve the task more directly and revise skill data to make use of the tool.

Granted I've let it mostly vibecode those tools, so they might be garbage. I should perhaps have it do a refactoring round to make more composable tools..

incrudibletoday at 5:50 AM

You are completely wrong, but one might get that impression from not using SOTA models in the Sonnet ballpark.

show 1 reply