All of that is sophistry in defense of fucking over those who choose not to cheat.
In this case yes. In general, the point of an honor system is supposed to be honor. It's great when it works, but unfortunately it's not working at Princeton.
If one is honorable only for the reward, is one really honorable though?
Either it is a principle or it is a strategy, can't be both.
In this case yes. In general, the point of an honor system is supposed to be honor. It's great when it works, but unfortunately it's not working at Princeton.