logoalt Hacker News

Veservtoday at 4:19 PM0 repliesview on HN

I am absolutely baffled by your response.

I was pointing out how even Apple, a entity who by all rights should have top-notch security, is still absolutely hopeless in the face of commonplace commercial, profit-motivated attackers.

Massive, extremely well-resourced divisions supported by management in a technically competent organization that is actually trying to solve the problem struggle to produce at best middling security that is inadequate against commonplace threats. This is not a prioritization problem; even if you do “everything right” you are still vulnerable to run-of-the-mill commercial attackers. This is a fundamental capability problem, like how we can not make a net positive fusion reactor right now.

It is actually unfair to blame these companies for not having a fusion reactor because they “were not trying hard enough”. Actual security is not a easy problem, and it is a great disservice to portray it as one that is only unsolved due to dunderheads being in charge since it leads to underestimating what actually needs to be done.

That is not to say that you can not do dramatically worse than the “gold standard” and also that most organizations are actually incompetent; but the “gold standard” is still objectively grossly inadequate. You need to be dramatically better than the 4 trillion dollar software company to reach adequate against prevailing threats.