logoalt Hacker News

graceful6800yesterday at 4:45 PM1 replyview on HN

There are actually three states:

- A bug exists and nobody knows

- A bug exists and some people know

- A bug exists and everyone knows

As an outside observer, there is no way for you to determine if a bug is in state one or two, you only know once it's in the third state.

Which is the entire problem here. Having the bug be known to everyone is a vastly improved state over being known to a few. Yes, the bug being completely unknown is better than being known to a few, but there is no way to ever know if that's the case.

From the outside, known to none and known to a few are indistinguishable, and thus both states are the worst possible case. The only remedy is to make the bug known to everyone such that it cannot be covertly exploited.


Replies

psychoslaveyesterday at 6:25 PM

That's not the whole picture though. Bugs exist anyway. The only practical concern is, which are practically most likely going to be used among all these bugs that yes exist and included in production.

show 1 reply