logoalt Hacker News

gunalxyesterday at 12:10 PM3 repliesview on HN

As much as I like graphene it is literary running on google hardware (atm) and uses asop. Even if it is a really good option is you want to run degoogled and secure android.


Replies

jasonvorheyesterday at 9:53 PM

You don't need any Google stuff on it. Isolated Play Services is an option, so is Play Store. It's not installed ootb. I don't get why you'd prefer to run less secure options on hardware that isn't on par with Pixels or iPhones and expect to get a secure OS.

throawayontheyesterday at 12:55 PM

Murena (/e/ os), Punkt, Volla use aosp

subscribedyesterday at 10:35 PM

I mean.... Android is aosp. And if you want to run degoogled GrapheneOS you just don't install Google services. Out of the box it does NOT contain any - but /e/OS ships with the privileged microG, which means that Android Auto or Google Play Store have privileged access to the phone.

So I'm not sure how can you suggest GOS is less "degoogled" while not shipping anything but allowing to install sandboxed / constrained play services, while comparing it to /e/OS which ships with a privileged plug.

Also, if you want to run a secure android, that's not /e/OS either.

show 1 reply