logoalt Hacker News

BirAdamyesterday at 10:02 PM6 repliesview on HN

This isn’t entirely true. A stylus is easy to understand, as is paper. Buildings of stone are relatively easy to grasp as well. Being a polymath was once doable. Today to truly master anything requires a lifetime of dedication.


Replies

onion2ktoday at 5:38 AM

Being a polymath was once doable.

Any reasonably intelligent child who can write some poetry, understand basic calculus, and has a working knowledge of chemistry would be heralded as a polymath if you dropped them into the Victorian era. The breadth of human knowledge is just bigger now.

j_maffeyesterday at 11:06 PM

But did the writer understand how the language got created and how the words shape her thoughts?

XorNotyesterday at 10:29 PM

Do you know how to make paper? Can you? Is it any good? Do you really understand it then?

fzeroracertoday at 2:17 AM

Do you know what went into Roman Concrete?

notahackeryesterday at 11:40 PM

Plenty of people master more than one domain. It's actually easier when the knowledge is more accessibly distributed in more generalised form, so you don't have to find out how to build stone vaults that don't collapse by trial and error

Ancient civilizations were full of laws people didn't control and property they didn't own, enforced by weapons they had no idea how to make imported from regions they knew nothing of and would have no opportunity to ever visit. And you didn't really understand the priest's explanation for why the gods had determined your infant sons deserved to die any better than the average person nowadays understands the antibiotics that could have enabled them not to die...