logoalt Hacker News

jrmgyesterday at 5:29 AM5 repliesview on HN

Surely there’s a middle ground where a roof is made of something big and panel-sized, rather than a conventional roof with panels as another layer on top?


Replies

ygrayesterday at 9:02 AM

This is the roof of an industrial building near here which seems to go with that idea:

https://nabendynamo.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/20210426_1...

While not quite panel-sized, it's much larger tiles and there's not another roof underneath. Probably makes most sense with a new roof, though. The problem is that when a roof lasts 50--80 years, that's not a very big market just for new roofs.

show 1 reply
IneffablePigeonyesterday at 5:50 AM

The middle ground is integrated solar panels, where you have normal sized panels but they are flush with the rest of the roof and there are no tiles underneath them. There are normal tiles surrounding the panels. This is the style I tend to see now for new builds, but it’s more expensive than just layering on the panels if your roof is already in good shape.

show 1 reply
KaiserProyesterday at 8:11 AM

THere is a middle ground which is this: https://www.wienerberger.co.uk/products/roof/in-roof-solar.h...

The big problem is that because there is no real ventilation, the panels get hotter and don't produce as much power.

What you put under them also has an effect on how waterproof your roof is long term, plus when you need to replace them finding ones that are the right size are also a pain.

show 1 reply
themafiatoday at 1:00 AM

You can do that.

If you experience any failure, like a falling tree limb, you're now _required_ to replace panels to restore the integrity of your home.

It's far simpler to be able to just restore a roof, which any builder can do, and then come back and restore the panel layer again later.