logoalt Hacker News

DoctorOetkertoday at 12:38 AM3 repliesview on HN

chemistry has more reactions than just with oxygen, oxygen alone is a poor indicator of life...


Replies

jerftoday at 1:08 AM

Oxygen is a highly reactive element that on a cosmological time frame instantly disappears by bonding with things. It is very difficult to come up with an explanation other than "life" for why an atmosphere would be full of oxygen; it may well be impossible to come up with an explanation other than "life" for why an atmosphere would be full of oxygen for 500 million years, especially on a ball of iron. Even having a transient explanation would be very difficult.

marcus_holmestoday at 1:09 AM

Not all living organisms use oxygen (even on our planet), true.

But you don't get free oxygen on a planet without life to continually produce it.

It's a good indicator of some forms of life.

adrianNtoday at 12:53 AM

We don’t have a lot of examples of technological life forms that don’t need oxygen.