logoalt Hacker News

ladbergyesterday at 4:55 PM2 repliesview on HN

Hypothetically you take the leading expert of a field and say "they believe in their own field too much - far more than I do as a layman - and therefore surely must have psychosis."

Why should I trust that your assessment is correct? Is it likely to ever be correct in the case of a doctor/mechanical engineer/athlete/economist/whatever? So why do so many people insist that an incredibly intelligent AI researcher has fallen into some obvious trap?


Replies

halfmatthalfcatyesterday at 6:24 PM

Because we're paying attention? A lot of "smart" people are lost in the AI sauce, grandstanding that they are going to change the very fabric of society. Generally leading experts in other fields are not making the same hyperbolic, self-indulgent, embarrassing statements.

show 2 replies
freejazzyesterday at 9:53 PM

Kinda funny that you are asking "how does one judge someone?" while apparently not understanding how to judge someone.