logoalt Hacker News

pclowesyesterday at 7:17 PM1 replyview on HN

Doesn’t classic search literally already do everything you fear LLM’s will?


Replies

NietzscheanNullyesterday at 7:46 PM

Certainly, but with (what I consider to be) a key distinction: classic search, by definition, must serve information from many distinct sources outside the control of the search company.

A search engine could certainly tamper with which of these sources they surface/rank higher (which I suspect happening more often of late), but they're still obliged by their nature to branch out and seek information from the broader world.

LLMs, on the other hand, are self-contained opaque monoliths that can be conditioned to deceive or obfuscate with devious cleverness, and all control over their behaviors is entirely concentrated in the hands of whatever corporation trains them.

show 1 reply