logoalt Hacker News

ameliusyesterday at 8:54 PM3 repliesview on HN

This is like saying a sculpture always existed, the sculptor just had to remove the superfluous material.

Or like a musical octave has only 12 semitones, so all music is just a selection from a finite set that already existed.

Sure the insane computation we're throwing at this changes our perspective, but still there is an important distinction.


Replies

npfriesyesterday at 10:05 PM

Bob Ross would like a word. He frequently talked about objects or features already existing, and using the tools at his disposal to “find” them.

paulddraperyesterday at 9:29 PM

The difference is that math answers (can answer) specific questions.

Like, "does the Riemann zeta function have zeroes that don't have real part 1/2," or "is there a better solution to the Erdős Unit Distance Problem."

The selection of question is matter of taste, but once selected, there is a definitive precise answer.