logoalt Hacker News

davebrentoday at 1:25 AM1 replyview on HN

Ordinary humans do novel things all the time. Where do you think LLMs got all the training data that their responses come from?


Replies

virgildotcodestoday at 1:40 AM

You're not quite addressing the question. More and more of the training data is now synthetic.

To be very specific - what novel things did the majority of the ~8 bil humans on Earth do say, yesterday, that you wouldn't otherwise dismiss as non-intelligent rehashing of the same tired patterns they always inhabit were those same actions attributed to LLMs?

What I'm getting at is that I think you're falling into the trap of thinking of the rare geniuses of human history, and furthermore their rare moments of accomplishment (relative to the long span of their lifetimes filled mostly without these accomplishments) when you think of "human intelligence", which is of course far overstating what actual human intelligence is.

show 1 reply