logoalt Hacker News

paxystoday at 5:07 PM7 repliesview on HN

Driving through an obviously flooded street thinking "I'll easily make it" and getting stuck in the middle? Yeah, these cars have achieved human level intelligence.


Replies

ge96today at 5:09 PM

Just get a jeep snorkle

show 3 replies
retrocryptidtoday at 5:50 PM

That being said... it's actually somewhat uncommon for humans to drive into flooded streets. To the degree that people think it's notable enough to take videos and post them to social media. I don't have the data, but would be interested to see how many times per passenger mile travelled human-directed and remotely-operated vehicles like Weymos drove into flooded streets.

I can appreciate the cameras and lidar on the Weymos don't give their remote operators a lot of good data about the depth of water on the road-way. As you point out, humans in cars often don't get this right. I think the humans that don't drive into deep water are the ones who a) give any amount of water on the roadway a big NOPE and b) people familiar with the local environment and use multiple visual clues to judge the true depth of the flooding.

show 2 replies
thegreatpetertoday at 5:39 PM

Let’s redirect the problem: it’s not the car, it’s the flooding! We should address that first

themafiatoday at 6:25 PM

Ask the car, in the sense you can, why it drove into the water.

Then ask the human.

I'm not sure you'd walk away the idea that they have equivalent intelligence. The human at least knew the water was there and took a risk, the car, presumably, had no idea what was in front of it and drove into it anyways.

fastballtoday at 5:32 PM

This is why I personally feel like Tesla's approach is more likely to "win". The fundamental blocker to self-driving cars is not sensing / sensor fusion, it is intelligence. And the Tesla approach seems much more likely to achieve functional intelligence than Waymo's.

show 3 replies
ramraj07today at 5:27 PM

They never advertised that they did. Its not even real true AI. They just struggle with new scenarios.

People drive into floods too. They just don't get sensational articles written about it, just posted on reddit.

show 2 replies