logoalt Hacker News

somebehemothtoday at 8:44 PM2 repliesview on HN

They did not write the rust code. AI wrote that code. Your response is side stepping the primary issue people have with the rewrite: no human has read and understood all the code AI wrote.


Replies

tomjakubowskitoday at 9:53 PM

I agree but would propose the weaker argument: no set of human contributors have, put together, read and understood all the code. Even in artisanal-coded projects of sufficient size, it's rare that any one human has read and understood all of it.

show 1 reply
IshKebabtoday at 10:35 PM

I had an actual look at the code, and because it's a translation it's not just straight up de novo slop. The bits I saw were fairly straightforward 1:1 translations, so the Bun developers should still be familiar with the overall structure and logic.

I still think it's mad, but not quite as mad as you might first think from the headlines.

show 1 reply