logoalt Hacker News

some-guytoday at 2:11 PM5 repliesview on HN

I don’t disagree that the expectations are higher, but token output hardly correlates to code output worthy of merging.


Replies

vips7Ltoday at 3:02 PM

It doesn’t necessarily mean shipping faster either. Speeding up code production doesn’t mean it speeds up qa, compliance, and the litany of other things. Everyone seems to forget Amdahl’s law.

Insanitytoday at 2:21 PM

Code quality matters to engineers. Find a senior manager who cares. Or worse, find a customer who cares.

While they obviously want a high quality product, no outages, a responsive system etc, I don’t think they necessarily understand why you need to avoid creating god-objects, need to reason about abstractions, etc.

show 4 replies
chocratestoday at 3:06 PM

On a task by task basis the code Claude generates is pretty good these days. The biggest issue I see is that it wants to rearchitect the code constantly and I have no faith in my tests anymore because Claude will just "fix" them

show 1 reply
joshribakofftoday at 2:23 PM

Thats why they said they optimize for effective output at the cost of higher token use. They didn’t say they are intending to have high token use, instead thet implied its a second order effect of seeking more effective output.

xenatoday at 2:22 PM

They don't care about quality as long as it works enough. It's a clown show all the way through.

show 1 reply