logoalt Hacker News

ETH_startyesterday at 3:01 AM5 repliesview on HN

I didn't say it's a good policy. I just said it's not some moral failing to not allow immigration. The implication of all these criticisms of the Republican administration's policy on immigration is that if they oppose immigration, they're racist. I find this to be a very manipulative form of emotional blackmail that abuses the racism allegation.


Replies

fc417fc802yesterday at 4:28 AM

I'd have more sympathy for that view if it were straightforward regulations being passed that placed strict and objective limits on the process. However what we have in practice appears to be a campaign to spread fear and uncertainty via underhanded regulations while feigning ignorance.

khanshyesterday at 3:23 AM

It is a moral failing when many times the immigrants coming to the US are coming from countries destabilized by our direct or indirect involvement. Reaping the benefits of our colonization while washing our hands of any of the consequences is morally wrong.

taravangian_yesterday at 3:27 AM

The current Republican regime’s only pro-immigration policy is white South Africans. Your knee jerk defense to a point no one made is inconsistent with the facts

eptcykayesterday at 6:35 AM

Choosing the suboptimal economic policy due to feels is a moral failure.

tardedmemeyesterday at 6:08 AM

Are you a libertarian? Do you support the right to travel or should you always need a travelling license to travel?

show 1 reply