logoalt Hacker News

alexwwangtoday at 11:00 AM1 replyview on HN

I think you need a skill to review those code by agent itself, but in a different role, not the one who wrote them. I did some research on this and developed a skill to get things done. By now it works well though I decide to prove and improve it with more tests. Dog food is not always delicious but not too bad either.


Replies

bottlepalmtoday at 4:08 PM

The problem is that I manually review the code before/after the review, as well as review the items to review themselves. You could easily put AI into a review infinite loop if you let it, and you also risk the code base going off the rails if you let AI go wild.

It's actually happened a few times where I need to back out entire features because AI went too far and I lost control/understanding of what the code is doing. Many people will give up at that point and let AI do everything - that is a mistake, at least right now and how you end up with unmaintainable vibe spaghetti slop.