logoalt Hacker News

sublinearyesterday at 9:22 PM4 repliesview on HN

Are we also saying it's acceptable to feed people junk because it's better than what they would cook?

At some point you're just making bad excuses for false scarcity.


Replies

cryzingeryesterday at 9:32 PM

I think it's both true that most LLM writing ("writing") sucks and that it's better than what a lot of people can produce unassisted. Which to me doesn't mean that we should roll over and accept LLM output as a lesser evil... it just means that the bar is so low it might as well be in hell, and rapidly getting lower :')

dspillettyesterday at 10:03 PM

They weren't saying it is aceptable, or making excuses, just stating how things are. Average reading and writing abilities seem to be dropping noticeably in many circles. Probably as a consequence of falling attention spans rather than an issue in is own right.

solumunusyesterday at 9:32 PM

It’s acceptable for someone to buy a ready meal or takeout if it’s better than what they can cook. Why wouldn’t it be? Is that the greatest choice for their personal development? Probably not, but life is complex and folk have limited capability and bandwidth for acquiring skills.

xienzeyesterday at 9:33 PM

Tell me your thoughts on the quality of LLM-generated code. I've never understood this attitude where people are absolutely disgusted by the slightest whiff of AI prose but will happily slurp up AI-generated code by the bucketful and proudly proclaim that it's OK because it's better than the average developer can produce.

show 2 replies