logoalt Hacker News

peoniclestoday at 3:15 AM4 repliesview on HN

We can take your train of thought further still. If AI ever becomes super good at lawyering, why would we even need law firms and lawyers at all?

We could feed legislation and constitution into the model and have it argue against other lawyer bots in court in front of a judge bot.


Replies

bluGilltoday at 11:28 AM

Because you need a human lawyer to appear before a jury. AI can fill in forms but not appear in person.

show 1 reply
NSUserDefaultstoday at 3:23 PM

Responsibility, reputation, reliability, human connection and empathy (ahem lawyers, right…)

patrickktoday at 6:08 AM

Brand value of the ‘prestigious’ law firms will still count for something in the minds of C suite executives (who of course will ensure they themselves are not trampled on by AI). The same dynamic will likely happen with high-powered consulting, big 4 audit/accounting firms and so on, even if inside those companies it’s just a shell of its former self.

close04today at 9:34 AM

Not buying the judge not part. A human being judged by a non-human will be very far in the future. Bots can’t be held accountable. It’s also an “us vs. them”, for some people it’s hard to accept being judged by a different gender, ethnicity, etc. A bot telling you to go to prison? Tough sell.

show 1 reply