logoalt Hacker News

meowfacetoday at 2:06 PM2 repliesview on HN

GPT-5.5 is the better programmer but Opus 4.8 remains the better system architect and product designer.

Codex is very "miss the forest for the trees", but is much better at successfully making large changes in large codebases. Claude Code makes more mistakes, but has more taste and a better grasp on idiomatic and elegant software development.

If you can afford to, I recommend juggling both.


Replies

theturtletalkstoday at 2:16 PM

Great analysis and follows my experience as well. Codex is better when you know how you want the design and the architecture and you drive the agent a lot more aggressively. Claude Code feels like more autopilot so executives and users who didn’t code before AI like it a lot more.

But I feel like an expert who can drive GPT aggressively will out perform Opus. It’s why some smart people I know are opting for GPT and have fallen off on Opus. It’s like asking an F1 driver to sit in a taxi.

show 2 replies
bayindirhtoday at 2:12 PM

I find arguing that a complex weighted graph has a taste is interesting.

This is not a jab, but a genuine curiosity of mine.

show 5 replies