logoalt Hacker News

thewebguydtoday at 4:55 PM4 repliesview on HN

> you aren't allowed to have any positive or nuanced opinion of the tech.

I'm finding this isn't unique to AI, it's as if our entire society has become black and white, overly tribal. There's little room for shades of gray now.

Look at the issue of public drug use by the unhoused in PNW cities, as an example. If you state any opinion other than silent acceptance of the issue, you get called a far-right nutjob. Trying to stand up for your right to a safe public space brands you as evil.

There's no room for a middle ground or nuance anymore. You are either entirely in one tribe, or entirely out.


Replies

michaelttoday at 5:21 PM

> Look at the issue of public drug use by the unhoused in PNW cities, as an example. If you state any opinion other than silent acceptance of the issue, you get called a far-right nutjob.

Are you having these conversations about politics in person? Or are these conversations happening on Twitter/Reddit/HN/whatever?

In my experience, online forums don't really work for political discussion for a bunch of reasons.

If you change to getting your fix of politics from long-form articles and radio-style scripted podcasts by professional journalists, you'll probably find there's a lot more room for nuance.

show 1 reply
the13today at 5:31 PM

Thanks to people being glued to social media & other rage bait machines on their phones.

coffeefirsttoday at 5:53 PM

This is a terminally online thing. It makes people more extreme. It also prevents them from realizing just how intense their POV is when everyone in their internet bubble is one upping each other.

In the real world I still encounter more moderation than not except from people who spend a lot of time on TikTok.

adampunktoday at 5:37 PM

>Look at the issue of public drug use by the unhoused in PNW cities, as an example.

This is such a wild thing to bring up unprompted.

show 1 reply