logoalt Hacker News

inglor_cztoday at 7:32 PM1 replyview on HN

Not necessarily, but it surely reeks of corruption and requires extra scrutiny.

Most professions can be abused to harm people and require some level of trust. Imagine that a developer's medailon cost 300 k.


Replies

kergonathtoday at 9:35 PM

I think FAANG developers would be better equipped than taxi driver to manage this. And besides, I don't think I am really against some kind of professional certification like actual engineers do. Right now SWE do not manage any of the downsides of what they inflict upon the world, and it's a damn shame. That said, having a limited number like taxi medallions in some cities would be stupid, even though I can see how it might make sense in a city.

I agree with you that it requires scrutiny and the process must be open and fair, like most things in a working democracy. I also think that it is not out of line to have mechanisms to ensure whoever is in a situation to kill, mug, kidnap or ransom you has no interest in doing so.