logoalt Hacker News

john-h-ktoday at 1:59 PM6 repliesview on HN

> allowing spicy autocomplete

Yknow, if the spicy autocomplete can solve difficult open math problems and build medium sized complex programming projects, it’s probably not useful to analyse it as an autocomplete anymore, even if that’s what you believe it is


Replies

fultonntoday at 2:23 PM

This bolsters OP's point.

It's the same as calling a gun a "powerful hole puncher".

There is a reasonable objection that a gun is such a powerful hole puncher that it is not merely a hole puncher. But the clear implication of that objection is that the user of the tool now has more responsibility and that the tool should be treated with more respect/care.

LLMs are a tool. The impact of using that tool is the responsibility of the end-user. As the tool at hand becomes more powerful, the care with which the end-user should treat that tool increases.

For some reason, with LLM-based systems, we seem to be going the opposite direction. As the tool becomes more capable people absolve themselves and others of more responsibility. This feels backwards to me.

(Aside: in a lot of ways, at least form a scientific and engineering perspective, modeling LLMs as "fundamentally auto-complete" is an incomplete theoretical model but one from which we can still get a lot of mileage.)

show 1 reply
yifanltoday at 3:23 PM

Between driving a car and driving a forklift, which of them would you like to see regulated more heavily?

show 1 reply
andy12_today at 2:14 PM

You don't get it. A human set up a software system allowing spicy autocomplete to solve open math problems if the appropriate keyword appears in its output.

show 1 reply
satisficetoday at 2:21 PM

“Autocomplete” does not represent an analysis of its problem-solving capability, but of its place in the social order and its expected social competence.

dogleashtoday at 4:04 PM

I don't spend much time interacting with zoomers, but I'm still surprised that "spicy $foo" sends fellow boomers through such a loop. I didn't have to puzzle it out, it was fun juxtaposition wordplay and when it's deployed well I still find it amusing.

show 1 reply
otabdeveloper4today at 2:54 PM

> the spicy autocomplete can solve difficult open math problems

No it can't. It can't even solve my son's 4th grade math homework. (This is a real use case for me, not a dumb benchmark.)

You just know nothing about math and are happy to parrot bullshit AI salesmen are selling you.

show 5 replies