logoalt Hacker News

inoffensivenametoday at 4:25 PM1 replyview on HN

> Someone naming their phone "Free Palestine, F Israel" is not a threat. Full stop.

The bluetooth device's name was BOMB. We're trained to treat even vague threats seriously.

The captain in this case is in a terrible situation. Do nothing, get pilloried for not taking action. Turn around, get pilloried for that.

I hope I'm never in this position because there are really no good options. All of you making comments have not been in this position, and were not there at the time with the information the captain had access to, and so are not in a position to judge the decision.


Replies

tga_dtoday at 4:49 PM

These are two separate incidents, please read the article. While the latest one is certainly arguable and I suspect most people would understand why someone would want to take it seriously (even if they themself would not), the earlier "Free Palestine" one seems absurd to label a threat, and I would be very curious how someone would justify it as such.