alt Hacker News>All that an inclusion of these new companies would accomplish is a bailout of their stockholders by pension funds and ETFs where millions of regular people shoulder all the downside risk.
Carvana is the poster child for this. It's astonishing that a company with a history of shady practices, and that has yet to offer a convincing explanation for why it is not a scam, is part of the S&P 500.
Replies
Im pretty sure Enron was in there in the past as well - 7th largest by revenue... that would make Carvana seem like nothing.
To answer your question honestly though -- the inclusion is mechanical based on criteria not policing based on opinion. Carvana being a history of shady practices is your opinion... (I would agree with you)
why go that far? herbalife moto is probably "we're a pyramid scheme scam" and they are 45% vs sp500 25% for last 12mo.
you'd better of investing scam500 than sp500 nowadays.
Ah, so you'd like the passive broad market index which contains the 500 biggest good companies?
Do tell us if you find one I guess.