alt Hacker News> this whole field is starting to feel more like a jobs program for mathematicians out of new ideas.
So sick of seeing phrases like this.
Science is not business. It is not about producing results that you personally think are important. It is understanding the nature of the universe for the sake of it.
Replies
> It is not about producing results that you personally think are important. It is understanding the nature of the universe for the sake of it.
Is this actually stated somewhere by the institutions that take taxpayer money for this research, or just your opinion?
Science and math are not the same thing, though. The concern is that physics, a science, has been sliding too much into math research - specifically talking about the foundations of particle physics.
That is, the concern is that instead of studying the real world, theoretical physicists are spending more and more time studying mathematical constructs and their properties.
There's a lot of ire for string theory. It's non-testable and wound up attracting lots of minds, funding, and resources. It hasn't seemingly led to any tangible results. Many scientists express anger about it and claim entire generations of progress were lost.
Please enlighten us how purely theoretical mathematical constructs, that are impossible to test, help us understand anything about our universe.