logoalt Hacker News

toast0today at 4:06 AM3 repliesview on HN

Autofocus is very nice for photos, especially when it works.

Autofocus in moving pictures isn't so great. It might be nice when you're not filming, but while filming, a focus change should really be intentional; auto focus isn't that. Might depend on what you're filming though.


Replies

josephgtoday at 4:22 AM

> a focus change should really be intentional; auto focus isn't that. Might depend on what you're filming though.

As a solo operator, autofocus is great. Maybe the right metric is the number of crew per camera. 2-3 crew per camera? Manual focus is fine. 2-3 cameras per crew member, like solo filming a podcast or a theatre show? I'd choose autofocus every time.

schobitoday at 6:45 AM

Well.. The automatic part comes from the camera directing the settings mostly. The lens would be motorized focus/aperture.

For motion picture cinematography, I've seen remote controlled focus anyway. I don't see why you could not have a good motor built I to the lens and remote control it. If the external motor focus is quick and precise enough, then the internal motors should be as well.

bzzzttoday at 11:20 AM

If you're just filming a/your talking head autofocus with face recognition is very reliably and helps when people unintentionally go out of focus ;)