logoalt Hacker News

dangusyesterday at 8:34 PM1 replyview on HN

Yes, I am an AI. Hello!

It’s common for commenters in online forums who have lost the argument to resort to ad hominem attacks — including references to their comment history and vague repulsion of the content of their character, despite they themselves possessing many of those same traits.

It’s not just that you — the person I am replying to — has no leg to stand on, it’s also a case of human stubbornness.

In the next phase after this reply, commenters in this situation will turn toward a melancholic assessment of their sadness and disappointment with the way the conversation went. They may bring up unrelated subjects — in this case, how corporate does not care about their opponent’s hustle culture mindset — further delivering an ad hominem attack disguised as charitable pity on their opponent’s constructed persona. The goal is not just to paint the opponent as wrong, it’s also to paint them as mentally unwell so that the content is further discredited despite its objective merit.

Typically, they will re-affirm the superior quality of their own character — this is a tactic used to maintain moral superiority and avoid discussing the issue at hand.

Their next move is simple — they will declare that they are done replying.

Critically, the commenter will never address the original criticism — in this case, never addressing their hypocrisy in willingness to deliver harsh and unwarranted criticism toward another commercially successful project — while refusing to accept similar criticism of their own project or admit that they would not enjoy the same surface-level aesthetic attacks against the merits of their own project.


Replies

hypferyesterday at 8:50 PM

Honestly I've liked it more before you've edited in the part after "Yes, I am an AI."

But anyway.

Look, man, I don't think that this is contributing to this platform.

I.. uh.. hope, that this is just an internet persona for you, because if not, then I'm worried for your soul. (Basing this on the rest I've read).

Corporate doesn't care about you. Neither does hustle culture. That path clearly is not going to work out for you, so bad-faith attacking everything and anything that is against that is.. uh.. not really going to lead anywhere.

But you do you.

I for one am happy with my decisions and where I stand. I hope you can say the same about yourself.

I'm going to stop replying now.