logoalt Hacker News

cardy31today at 12:25 AM5 repliesview on HN

Because most people in tech never took a philosophy course or an ethics course and think that tech is obviously a good for the world and that there are no downsides to advancing tech. So any efforts that try to apply ethics to it are overreaching, ignorant, and futile in the face of the good that is tech!


Replies

wolpolitoday at 3:48 AM

Or alternatively, it is plain and obvious that Anthropic is using ethics to justify business decisions.

borskitoday at 1:53 AM

Not any efforts.

But this one is certainly allowed to be a dumb effort, if it is.

Not all things that are called “ethical” or “safety” are worth doing.

siva7today at 6:34 AM

So i have big news for you my friend as i'm not sure you understand such courses. Taking an ethics course won't make you a more ethical person.. and taking a philosophy course neither.

show 1 reply
vzcxtoday at 2:25 AM

Or... they just disagree with Anthropic's ethical stances and approach to applying them?

enraged_cameltoday at 1:14 AM

I like this take. Especially because one of the sibling comments framed Anthropic's stance as "paternalism." Trying to be ethical and to minimize harm, even at great expense to one's finances and reputation, is paternalistic apparently.

show 2 replies