logoalt Hacker News

silexiatoday at 1:24 PM6 repliesview on HN

Farmer here. We have had our access to medications for livestock severely curtailed over recent years. The screw work is already in Texas. This means there will be massive amounts of suffering we cannot help with.

If we had tariffs, this northward movement of herds would not happen. And American farmers who have to follow high minimum wage rules and strict environmental rules could compete.


Replies

mrngldtoday at 6:02 PM

It wasn't herds of cattle moving through the jungles of Central America that likely helped the screwworm breach the barrier we'd been maintaining for decades. It was mass human migration. Once they managed to move north any animal was a potential host, not just commercial critters.

And even then it probably could've been held at bay and fought back south, except Mexico in particular was extremely sensitive about any suggestion they might not have everything completely under control.

Even so, the US started contingency plans a while ago just in case, and construction of the new facility. The comments here are quick to try to take a jab at the government but short of nuking southern Mexico from sea to glowing sea once the screwworms breached the line, and that breach wasn't US territory, don't know how this was ever going to play out differently unless the locals at every step of the way stepped up.

show 1 reply
Aefiamtoday at 6:21 PM

northward movement of herds are already banned between mexico and the usa because of screwworms, so tariffs are irrelevant. Also transmission also occurs through wildlife so banning that is also not enough.

snowwrestlertoday at 5:24 PM

Tariffs would not stop the screw worm, which lives half of its life as a winged fly.

show 1 reply
BobaFloutisttoday at 3:54 PM

>We have had our access to medications for livestock severely curtailed over recent years.

Oh no, tell me it's not ivermectin...

show 5 replies
pstuarttoday at 5:58 PM

> If we had tariffs, this northward movement of herds would not happen.

Please explain how that would work.

sanktangliatoday at 5:31 PM

Ahh yes tariffs will solve this problem,how's it doing solving all those other problems?