logoalt Hacker News

ryandrakeyesterday at 1:24 AM2 repliesview on HN

That’s the thing about principled positions. If you believe censorship is wrong, then it is equally wrong no matter what the topic is.


Replies

no-name-hereyesterday at 5:19 AM

Do you believe it’s only censorship where context shouldn’t be applied? Like if someone had a principled view "violence is wrong", would non-lethal violence in a clear case of self-defense be “equally wrong” as the guy who personally killed tens of thousands of captured POWs (Blokhin)? As “violence is violence”?

no-name-hereyesterday at 1:44 AM

>> Would bioweapon instruction restrictions be equivalent to disallowing reporting on whether the government is massacring large numbers of citizens in your city?

> If you believe censorship is wrong, then it is equally wrong no matter what the topic is.

Are you agreeing with that view, or merely saying it’s a theoretical view but you think such believers are wrong?