logoalt Hacker News

ceejayozlast Sunday at 3:59 PM1 replyview on HN

Again, you asserted:

> There definitely are ways to look at each tax and determine its worth, in a non-partisan way.

You then asserted those are:

> Academic panels, economists writing papers on impacts of various policies like rent control, monetary policy, and yes, taxes.

But Marx himself is an example of that process - an economist, writing papers on all this. You clearly don't agree with his conclusions, so now we're... right back where we started?


Replies

satvikpendemlast Sunday at 4:01 PM

Nowhere did I say I have to agree with their conclusions to think that the work they're doing on analysis of policy is worthwhile, while your logic seems to be that it is not, which is what I disagree with. If that's not your argument then apologies.

show 1 reply