logoalt Hacker News

55555yesterday at 7:07 AM2 repliesview on HN

Something I've always wondered, because I'm a bit of a contrarian and I wonder if we're really any different: Could an American citizen hack and steal from Iranians and Russians with impunity from America? The issues that prevent the US from extraditing Russians who hack us -- don't they work both ways?


Replies

entunoyesterday at 10:51 AM

Legally speaking, no - it would still be a criminal offence.

Practically speaking, there is zero chance that the USA would extradite someone to Iran, even if they weren't currently at war with them. Whether they did anything about it would probably depend on exactly what the situation was - there's a big of difference between targeted IRGC or defence systems and ransomwaring an Iranian hospital or scamming random citizens.

Where they'd probably get you is if you tried to monetise it, and get stolen/extorted cryptocurrencies (or whatever) into your bank account. But that could easily fall under tax evasion laws rather than computer misuse ones, because they'd be a lot easier to prove in court.

show 1 reply
dolkycapeyesterday at 11:47 AM

As far as I know it has never happened. On the contrary, when Alejandro Caceres admitted to ddosing North Korea - taking down all their public websites for a week - he was questioned by the FBI who decided to take no further action.

https://www.wired.com/story/p4x-north-korea-internet-hacker-...

So hostile countries should be fair game for Americans who want a side-hustle. Plenty of Russian targets that could be profitable.