logoalt Hacker News

ForHackernewsyesterday at 10:29 PM2 repliesview on HN

Your objection is that they should be "designing it right from the beginning" but that applies to all realms of endeavour. The reason they didn't is human frailty.

If everyone simply designed everything right from the beginning we would live in nirvana.


Replies

andaiyesterday at 11:32 PM

I read an article about business which had this classification, "Would be weird if it worked", "Might work", and "Would be weird if it didn't work" and argued that you want to be in the last category.

In engineering we aspire to a slightly stronger standard: "I made it physically impossible to fuck this up."

tptacekyesterday at 10:31 PM

You've completely missed my point. I don't even accept the premise of the JWT standard. But the eventual migration to safer default settings, in a format that continues to expend implementation effort to support settings nobody should use, is in fact a practical engineering problem with the standard.

show 1 reply