logoalt Hacker News

JacobAsmuthyesterday at 10:31 PM12 repliesview on HN

You'd say that Google Maps hasn't improved much in the last 20 years?


Replies

da_chickentoday at 1:19 AM

My best friend bought a house. She noticed within the first month that the name of the road she lived on was misspelled in Google Maps. Specifically, it's a slightly unusual spelling of the road name. Like "Chickorie" vs "Chickory". It's particularly annoying because there's a road the next town over with the traditional spelling. It doesn't even share address numbers, but Google Maps still frequently misdirects people.

It's correct everywhere else. The road sign, the municipal tax parcel GIS, the post office, Apple Maps, MapQuest, OpenStreetMaps. All of them had the correct name, except Google Maps. So she reported it through Google Maps. And reported it. And reported it. Every few months she reports it again. She's asked friends to report it as well.

It's still wrong.

She bought her house in 2015.

show 1 reply
jazzyjacksonyesterday at 10:33 PM

It’s doing a great job making sure I know where Burger King is when zooming into a city

show 3 replies
asdfftoday at 12:17 AM

It is still drawing bike lane networks in cemeteries and random bits of grass and pavement. So no. The way I see it is is actually worse than it was in 2006. When I opened it today it asked me if I would like to see Dua Lipa's recommended restaurants.

awinter-pytoday at 1:28 AM

odds of a given street being labeled on gmaps for android still feels like 50/50 unless you get the zoom exactly right

show 1 reply
bltyesterday at 11:57 PM

Not relative to its available resources. For example, there's still no option to penalize intersections. I'm still getting absurd side-street routes and unprotected lefts/crossings to save 1 minute on a 20-minute trip.

boelboelyesterday at 10:42 PM

It's been up and down for about 8-12 years. Problems get fixed and new ones get added without a particular direction, at least that's what it feels like as a regular user. Some come back years after they were first fixed.

walt_gratayesterday at 10:37 PM

Id say it improved until about 2016, since then the additions have generally made the software worse.

More overlays and popups More needlessly verbose navigation instructions Less predictable routes.

Thats just the start

driverdantoday at 12:05 AM

Maps peaked after Google acquired Waze in 2013 and integrated the data. Since then they've added worthless annoying social features and more advertising.

intexpressyesterday at 10:40 PM

Apple Maps has been better than Google Maps for at least 10 years and nowadays the way that Google Maps improves is often just by copying Apple Maps

show 1 reply
daedrdevyesterday at 10:59 PM

Google has said to turn right at an intersection where you are turning left for years because it doesn't know about a T shaped intersection that tens of thousands use a day.

ElectricalTearsyesterday at 10:42 PM

Maps thinks it's fine to do a u-turn on the Sydney harbour bridge.

show 2 replies
dlev_pikayesterday at 10:41 PM

Google: HOW ABOUT SOME AI ON IT?!? You know you want it.

Lmao