logoalt Hacker News

AbuAssartoday at 9:26 AM8 repliesview on HN

nope, I prefer open in new tab by default


Replies

kpopendurertoday at 9:34 AM

In general, it's better not to force an action onto users. You might prefer things opening in a new tab, but you always have that option. If it's forced on users, it is frustrating for those who would prefer that not to happen.

show 2 replies
chrysopracetoday at 9:36 AM

That's a good user setting, but as opening in the same tab is the default browser behaviour then it should really stay that way. Opening in a new tab takes control away from the user.

show 3 replies
netfortiustoday at 12:41 PM

100% agree. I had to install a browser extension when I use HN with such (vs app on android, when it does it by default), just to force open links to new tabs.

show 1 reply
giancarlostorotoday at 1:40 PM

I'd rather have an icon next to the link that implies "Open in new Tab" like one of these with the arrow:

https://www.flaticon.com/free-icons/new-tab

show 1 reply
Telaneotoday at 12:37 PM

I too prefer that, but i don't want to force that choice on othet people.

CTRL+left click is ingrained in me now anyway.

rafterydjtoday at 1:05 PM

I do as well, but I think it's good practice to put something like in a user preference setting somewhere if you are going to stray from default browser/system behavior.

akoboldfryingtoday at 11:34 AM

And people who prefer the other way can just hold down _____ while clicking to open it in the current tab instead.

Good ol' _____-clicking saves the day again!

show 1 reply
AbuAssartoday at 10:54 AM

why the downvotes, I meant to demonstrate that I prefer the current behaviour so the site developer knows.

show 1 reply