logoalt Hacker News

throwaway240403today at 12:13 AM2 repliesview on HN

QNAP unforgivably uses a proprietary version of ZFS with their own extensions that are not compatible with mainline OpenZFS. It can only zfs send/receive to other QNAP devices. While your data is protected like any other ZFS system, it is _NOT_ interoperable. You can not take a zpool out of a QNAP system and access it on another system with ZFS. I discovered this painfully the hard way, and won't buy from them again, unless I plan to wipe the software and run something open.


Replies

scheme271today at 1:35 AM

I think the ZFS changes were due to needing a way to allow qnap systems to expand zfs pools. The raidz expansion features in openzfs probably took too long for qnap to wait.

show 1 reply
lazidetoday at 12:55 AM

Amusingly, most of my old qnap hardware ran Ubuntu pretty well