logoalt Hacker News

stevemk14ebryesterday at 2:58 PM3 repliesview on HN

An LLM is not thinking, assuming and relating it to thought and universal truths is nonsense.


Replies

dgellowyesterday at 2:59 PM

We inflicted that to ourselves by picking the most confusing terminology ever. "No, reasoning isn't thinking. No when the model says it thinks it's not actually thinking... No an agent isn't actually a creature with agency... No, when we say it hallucinates it doesn't, like, actually hallucinate"

show 1 reply
coldteatoday at 12:49 PM

How is it's process (inputs, training weights, processing those weights based on an initial given state -prompt-) different than how a brain thinks? And is it a difference of architecture and scale (like an ENIAC and a Apple Silicon M5) or a difference of fundamental operation?

brookstyesterday at 3:11 PM

Did you mean sentient?