logoalt Hacker News

shevy-javatoday at 10:07 AM5 repliesview on HN

Can it really be called evolution? That sort of implies an improvement.

Interestingly enough, the default GTK file chooser also sucks. I notice this nowadays because I broke something in my setup but I don't know what, and the default file chooser does not remember anything I do. Prior to that I found out that for opening files via the browser, I need to have e. g. xdg-desktop-portal-gtk running. Well, my browser never told me that; it just silently failed to download anything, I could not choose any local file for file upload. I only found out eventually, but when I found out, the fix was easy, but still, the question is why such things break silently. This is simply incredibly poor engineering and design, and that happens on linux too. That way they'll never achieve linux desktop of the year. The decision makers here are just horribly bad at designing anything. The whole GTK team fell victim to this, now that it is a GNOMEy toolkit only.

When we ever get one-toolkit-that-fixes-everything (well ...), hopefully they are really allowing only mega-smart people who can think objectively and try to IMPROVE things rather than regress or take away functionality willy-nilly style (as the GNOMEy devs do).


Replies

edoloughlintoday at 12:40 PM

One thing that drives me nuts every time I save a new file or 'save as'. File chooser appears and I automatically start typing to enter/change the filename. But the filter input always gets focus and now I'm filtering the list of visible files instead of naming my file...

(Yes, I know I could try to submit a PR but I don't have the energy to figure out the Gnome governance process.)

show 1 reply
inigyoutoday at 11:15 AM

at this point GNOME is a joke. I'm not sure KDE is always better but at least KDE is clearly trying. btw Wayland is also a project of the GNOME team and almost everyone is using the KDE extensions to it to make it suck less.

show 3 replies
wolfi1today at 10:29 AM

evolution need not necessarily be an improvement, foe example mammals have a blind spot in their eyes because of the optic nerve, octopuses don't have a blind spot. but octopuses were before mammals

show 2 replies
jancitoday at 12:06 PM

I never understood why file open/save dialog is a separate thing. I want to use my file manager to open and save files!

show 2 replies
kenjacksontoday at 2:36 PM

How is this not an improvement?