logoalt Hacker News

jsLavaGoattoday at 1:24 PM2 repliesview on HN

What interests a mathematician isn't 100% the same as what interests the physicist. All I'm saying is there is some math there that's interesting and people should see it once for the math.


Replies

lrasinentoday at 2:22 PM

And then there are us engineers. I don't care much either way whether Maxwell's equations are ∇F = J or some other form, as long as it makes the problem easier to solve.

If I were in the GA Marketing Committee I'd publish a paper with suitably hand-picked worked examples where the vector approach is long and tedious, and GA version is short and sweet.

show 2 replies
eigenspacetoday at 1:29 PM

I guess I'd say my point though is that the gauge structure is the mathematically interesting part of Maxwell's equations. (i.e. the fact that `F` is a closed differential form).

Without it, I think it'd be of significantly less mathematical interest because it'd lose almost all of its geometric properties.

show 1 reply